Genomic Perl

Book Reviews

Rex Dwyer has produced a book, Genomic Perl, which bridges the gap. As well as teaching basic Perl programming techniques to biologists, it introduces many useful genetic concepts to those already familiar with programming. Of course, as a programmer and not a biologist, I'm by no means qualified to assess the quality of that side of the book, but I certainly learned a lot from it.

The first chapter, for instance, taught the basics of DNA transcription and translation, the basics of Perl string handling, and tied the two concepts together with an example of transcription in Perl. This is typical of the format of the book - each chapter introduces a genetic principle and a related problem, a Perl principle which can be used to solve the problem, and a program illustrates both. It's a well thought-out approach which deftly caters for both sides of the audience.

However, it should be stressed that the book is a substitute neither for a good introductory book on Perl nor a good textbook on genetics; and indeed, I think it will turn out to be better for programmers who need an over-arching idea of some of the problems involved with bioinformatics than for biologists who need to turn out working code. For instance, when it states that a hash is the most convenient data structure for looking up amino acids by their codons, it doesn't say why, or even what a hash is. On the other hand, amino acids and codons are both explained in detail.

The book covers a wide range of biological areas - from the structure of DNA to building predictive models of species, exploring the available databases of genetic sequences including readers of the GenBank database and an implementation of the BLAST algorithm, phylology, protein databases, DNA sequence assembly and prediction, restriction mapping, and a lot more besides. In all, it's a good overview of the common areas in which biologists need computer programs.

There's a significant but non-threatening amount of math in there, particularly in dealing with probabilities of mutation and determining whether or not events are significant, but I was particularly encouraged to see discussion of algorithmic running time; as the author is primarily a computer science professor and secondarily a bioinformaticists, this should not be too surprising. However, a significant number of bioinformaticists tend to produce code which works... eventually. Stopping to say "well, this is order n-to-the-6 and we can probably do better than that" is most welcome.

Onto the code itself. The first thing any reader will notice about the book is that the code isn't monospaced. Instead, the code is "ground", pretty-printed, as in days of old. This means you'll see code snippets like:

next unless $succReadSite; ## dummy sinks have no successor
my $succContigSite = $classNames->find($succReadSite);

Now, I have to admit I really like this, but others may find it difficult to read, and those who know slightly less Perl may find it confusing - the distinction between '' and " (that's two single quotes and a double quote) can be quite subtle, and if you're going to grind Perl code, regular expressions really, really ought to be monospaced. "$elem =~ /^[(^\[(]*)(\(.*\))?$/;" is just plain awkward.

The code is more idiomatic than much bioinformatic code that I've seen, but still feels a little unPerlish; good use is made of references, callbacks and object oriented programming, but three-argument for is used more widely than the fluent Perl programmer would have it, and things like

    main();

    sub main {

        ...

    }

worry me somewhat. But it works, it's efficient, and it's certainly enough to get the point across.

The appendices were enlightening and well thought-out: the first turns an earlier example, RNA structure folding, into a practical problem of drawing diagrams of folded RNA for publication; the other two tackle matters of how to make some of the algorithms in the text more efficient.

All in all, I came away from this book not just with more knowledge about genetics and biology - indeed, some of what I learned has been directly applicable to some work I have - but also with an understanding of some of the complexity of the problems geneticists face. It fully satisfies its goals, expressed in the preface: teaching computer scientists the biological underpinnings of bioinformatics, providing real, working code for biologists without boring the programmers, and providing an elementary handling of the statistical considerations of the subject matter. While it will end up being more used by programmers getting into the field, it's still useful for the biologists already there, particularly when combined with something like James Tisdall's book or Learning Perl. But for the programmer like me, interested in what biologists do and how we can help them do it, it's by far the clearest introduction available, and I would heartily recommend it.